From tactics to strategy: escaping the CRO hamster wheel

Talia calls it the “deadly hamster wheel of optimization.” It’s when marketers see low conversion numbers, run to Google for “best practices,” or copy a competitor’s landing page in hopes of quick wins.

“We’re all sounding the same and doing the same,” she says. “The reason we get stuck in tactics is because we don’t have a good strategy. Google Analytics tells you where the problem is, but it doesn’t tell you what led to it.”

Without a strategy rooted in understanding the customer journey, optimization efforts become repetitive and superficial. Talia’s solution is to start with a deep dive into what motivates customers emotionally—not just the functional benefits they expect from a product or service.

Remote video URL

The science behind emotional targeting

When Talia transitioned from social media marketing to CRO, she noticed a glaring gap: most optimizations focused solely on usability and persuasion tactics without asking why people were buying in the first place.

She points to research by neuroscientist Antonio Damasio, who famously said, “We are not thinking machines that feel; we are feeling machines that think.” Every decision, from choosing a SaaS tool to buying a watch, is driven primarily by emotion.

According to Talia, emotional targeting means:

• Understanding how customers feel before finding your solution
• Identifying the pain points and fears influencing their decision-making
• Knowing how they want to feel after solving the problem
• Communicating those emotional outcomes throughout the experience

This approach shifts CRO from “What can I change on the page?” to “What problem can I solve for my customer?”

An example from a “boring” industry

Marketers sometimes assume emotional targeting works best for luxury or lifestyle brands. Talia proves otherwise.

She shared the story of a client selling Q&A software for engineers, a product that might seem dry and purely functional. Through emotional targeting research, Talia’s team discovered a striking insight: many QA engineers felt undervalued in their companies.

“They’d say, ‘I do super important work… but everyone rolls their eyes when I speak up because I slow things down.’ That’s a huge emotional trigger,” she explains.

Rather than focusing solely on features and pricing (which were similar to competitors), Talia’s team reframed the messaging: using the product would help engineers be recognized and appreciated for their contributions.

By weaving this emotional outcome through product pages, ads, and email campaigns, the company saw significant conversion lifts. The takeaway? Every product, no matter how technical, can connect with customers on a human level.

Remote video URL

How to uncover emotional triggers

Emotional targeting starts with research, not guesswork. Talia recommends combining qualitative and quantitative methods to build a complete picture.

Here are some strategic questions she uses when auditing a customer journey:

1. Is the messaging focused on the company or the customer?
2. Are the customer’s pain points clearly reflected on each page?
3. Do visuals, colors, and design elements support the emotional message?
4. Can the visitor quickly see the emotional outcome of using the product?

These questions go beyond typical UX checks like “How many form fields?” or “Is the button visible?” They require understanding the why behind customer actions, not just the what.

Choosing what to optimize first

Not every business has the traffic or resources to run large-scale A/B tests. For smaller teams, Talia advises focusing on bigger, strategic changes rather than micro-optimizations.

“If I’m Amazon, I can test the shade of an orange button,” she says. “But most of us can’t. We have to zero in on problem solving.”

Her recommendation:

1. Identify the stage of the customer journey that’s underperforming.
2. Form a hypothesis about the emotional gap causing friction.
3. Test a targeted change—copy, imagery, offer—that addresses this emotional need.
4. Measure results, then apply what you’ve learned across channels.

This way, every test is either a win or a valuable learning opportunity.

Remote video URL

Using AI without losing the human touch

Artificial intelligence has become a popular tool in marketing, but Talia warns against using it as a shortcut.

“If you feed ChatGPT a generic prompt, you’ll get generic answers. And that’s why everyone starts to sound the same,” she says.

Instead, she suggests using AI as a strategic partner:

• Input rich, customer-specific insights from your emotional targeting research.
• Use AI to brainstorm ideas, test variations, or synthesize findings.
• Share those insights across teams—from sales to product—to create a unified customer understanding.

The rule is simple: garbage in, garbage out. AI amplifies the quality of the data and thinking you bring to it.

Why technology changes but people don’t

CRO trends come and go (personalized landing pages, minimalism, AI) but Talia insists the fundamentals remain constant.

“You can’t use any tool unless you have strategy behind it,” she says. “Your superpower should be knowing your customers. Once you have that, you can use any tool and any technology.”

This means emotional targeting isn’t just another tactic—it’s the foundation that makes all other optimizations work harder.

Remote video URL

Building a customer-focused culture

Leaders often struggle to get buy-in for customer-first strategies, especially across product, UX, and marketing teams. Talia’s advice is to start small:

• Do the research. You don’t need permission to run emotional targeting interviews or surveys.
• Run a low-risk experiment. Test a message or creative variation that speaks to a key emotional trigger.
• Share results internally. Show colleagues how the emotional approach performed compared to generic messaging.

This step-by-step method proves the value of emotional targeting without requiring an expensive redesign or overhaul.

Key takeaways for marketers and UX professionals

From the conversation, several actionable insights emerge:

• Shift focus from tactics to strategy. Stop chasing quick wins and start addressing the root causes of low conversions.
• Map the emotional journey. Know how customers feel before, during, and after engaging with your brand.
• Use emotional triggers in all touchpoints. Messaging, visuals, and even navigation should align with the emotional outcome you’re promising.
• Test with purpose. Make changes that solve a specific customer problem, not just because it’s a “best practice.”
• Leverage AI thoughtfully. Feed it meaningful insights to get meaningful outputs.
• Create organizational buy-in. Share research and test results across teams to embed customer focus into company culture.

The bottom line

Emotional targeting isn’t a “soft” approach, it’s a strategic method for unlocking higher conversions and stronger customer loyalty. By stepping off the hamster wheel of surface-level CRO tactics, teams can create experiences that resonate deeply and drive measurable results.

“Technology changes. People don’t,” Talia said. “Your superpower should be knowing your customers. Once you have that, you can use any tool and any technology.”

Episode links

• GetUplift – Talia Wolf’s company
• Emotional Targeting by Talia Wolf
• Nathan Isaacs – host of Insights Unlocked
• Talia Wolf – guest, founder of GetUplift and author of Emotional Targeting
• Antonio Damasio – neuroscientist and researcher on emotion and decision-making
• Unlock higher conversions: understanding what users really want: This on-demand webinar explores how to go beyond analytics to uncover hidden friction, streamline user journeys, and enhance conversions by leveraging real customer feedback
• Optimizing conversion rates for retail and consumer brands: This guide provides practical strategies for improving ecommerce performance, reducing friction, and maximizing ROI through optimized digital experiences
• The power of emotional data: This on-demand webinar delves into concept and campaign testing methods that use emotional feedback to inform marketing strategy and messaging
• How to create customer journey maps to increase conversions: This blog post details how mapping the customer journey—including emotional touchpoints—can identify barriers and opportunities to boost conversions